<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=690758617926394&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">
The Complete Payroll Blog

When do employee background checks cross the line?

Posted by Complete Payroll | May 19, 2018 7:00:00 AM

When do employee background checks cross the line_ - Complete Payroll

Employers have become well-attuned to the importance of selecting job candidates that are qualified and will fit well with the organization’s culture.  Prior to extending an offer of employment to a viable candidate, best practices in conducting a background check are to use a variety of methods to assess skills, verify professional experience, and to check in with a candidate’s references.

Consent from the applicant

Some employers opt to use a third-party consumer reporting services to assist with reference checking and securing consumer reports, such as criminal background checks, education verification checks, and motor vehicle reports.  This practice is compliant with the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) as long as the employer discloses to the applicant, in writing, that the report may be obtained for employment-related purposes. Such a disclosure must be made on a consent form that is separate from the employment application.  Once the applicant’s consent is obtained in writing, the employer may obtain this report. 

New call-to-action

Adverse action

 Should an organization opt to disqualify a candidate based on the results of a consumer report, the employer is required to follow an “adverse action procedure,” which includes sending the candidate a pre-adverse action notice, a copy of the consumer report, a final adverse action notice and a summary of rights under the FCRA. 

Conviction records vs. arrest records

The EEOC has established guidance for employers with respect to the use of criminal history information.  The guidance disallows employers from basing hiring decisions on an applicant’s arrest record; rather, the conviction record is the only criteria that may be used in this regard. 

Checks must be "job-related"

The EEOC further requires that all background checks be “job-related” and “consistent with business necessity.” For example, it is reasonable for a financial sector employer to conduct a credit history check on a job candidate. There are generally three factors that an employer may take into consideration when determining if the criminal conviction meets this burden:   

  • Nature and gravity of the offense
  • Time elapsed since the conviction or completion of a sentence
  • Nature of the position sought

When checking credit score or credit history

Employers must use extreme caution when basing an employment decision on an employee’s credit score or history.  While the federal law allows employers to use an applicant’s credit history in the employment application process as long as doing so is job-related and consistent with business necessity, ten states currently have adapted limitations on the use of credit information for employment selection purposes: 

  • California
  • Colorado
  • Connecticut
  • Hawaii
  • Illinois
  • Maryland
  • Nevada
  • Oregon
  • Vermont
  • Washington

"Ban the box" legislation

Federal law does not prohibit employers from inquiring about criminal convictions on an employment application.  However, ten states have passed legislation disallowing employers from asking about criminal convictions on job applications; also known as “ban the box”:

  • California
  • Hawaii
  • New Jersey
  • Colorado
  • Connecticut
  • Massachusetts
  • Maryland
  • Minnesota
  • New Mexico
  • Rhode Island

Some closing thoughts...

Ultimately, an employer should assess the specific role for which it is hiring and the relevance of an individual’s criminal or credit history information in making its employment selections. This will aid in determining the necessity for conducting the background checks on specific roles that are engaged in working with the public, with vulnerable populations or with sensitive, proprietary information.

Specifically, employers in the banking and financial services industry as well as those who work with young children, the elderly or individuals with disabilities are strongly urged to implement a background check in their hiring process.  Offers of employment should be contingent to the results of background checks; thus, if any disqualifying information appears on a candidate’s background check, the employer will easily be able to negate the preliminary offer of employment. The candidate will have the right to dispute the accuracy of the background check information by directly contacting the consumer agency; this right should be communicated to a candidate in order to ensure that employment background checks comply with the FCRA.

Employee Background Check Toolkit

To assist employers that wish to run background, credit and employment history checks on their potential candidates - both properly and effectively - we've created the Employee Background Check Toolkit. It's a free, all-in-one resource that includes a form bundle of how-to guides, authorization forms, policy and letter templates and much more. Click the image button below to access the free toolkit.

Get help with Employee Background Checks.

Complete Payroll offers employee background checks as a service to its clients. Click here to set up a background check or simply learn more about the service.

New call-to-action

Also, check out our comprehensive resource page on employee background checks that consolidates all the information, blog posts and other resources about running background checks on employees and potential hires in one place.

Topics: Labor law, Employees, Human resources

Written by Complete Payroll

We do payroll, HR, timekeeping and more for employers all over the country from a small, rural town in Upstate New York. And we're constantly publishing articles and other resources to help business owners, HR managers or anyone that helps manage a workforce. Welcome to Payroll Country!

Are you using our free resources?

We're constantly publishing free tools to help with payroll, HR and other administrative objectives.

Complete COVID-19 Resources for Employers
New call-to-action

Subscribe to instant blog email notifications

Recent Posts

General Disclaimer

The materials and information available at this website and included in this blog are for informational purposes only, are not intended for the purpose of providing legal advice, and may not be relied upon as legal advice.  The employees of Complete Payroll are not licensed attorneys. This information and all of the information contained on this website are provided pursuant to and in compliance with federal and state statutes. It does not encompass other regulations that may exist, including, but not limited to, local ordinances. Complete Payroll makes no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, currentness, suitability, or validity of the information on this website and does not adopt any information contained on this website as its own. All information is provided on an as-is basis.  Please consult an attorney to obtain advice with respect to any particular question or issue.